A line of water bottles that had become a symbol of environmental responsibility has been removed from the shelves of Canada's leading outdoor gear retailer over concerns about a chemical used in its manufacture.
The Mountain Equipment Co-op, which is based in Vancouver, British Columbia, removed the bottles, sold under the brand name Nalgene, and other polycarbonate containers from its 11 large-scale stores on Wednesday. The retailer said that it would not restock the bottles, which are made by Nalge Nunc International in Rochester, a unit of Thermo Fisher Scientific, until Health Canada completed a review of bisphenol-a, or B.P.A., a chemical used to make hard, transparent plastics as well as liners for food cans. “We've been following the B.P.A. issue for at least three years,” said Tim Southam, a spokesman for Mountain Equipment. “The decision we've taken this week does not mean that polycarbonate products will never return to our stores. We're just seeking some certainty about this chemical.”
Church and environmental groups in Canada have mounted campaigns against bottled water because of concerns about the huge amount of plastic used in containers. As a result, the reusable Nalgene bottles have become ubiquitous on college campuses and elsewhere.
Polycarbonate plastic, which can only be produced by using B.P.A., creates bottles that are transparent and almost as hard as glass, but particularly shatter-resistant. Recently, however, the use of B.P.A.-based plastics in food containers has been questioned in Canada by Environmental Defence, a Toronto-based group. Environmentalists in the United States are also raising concerns about the chemical. Last year, San Francisco's board of governors passed a local law banning the use of the chemical in children's products. B.P.A. was removed from the ordinance before it went into effect, however, after an industry lawsuit. Critics point to studies dating back to 1936 showing that the chemical can disrupt the hormonal system.
While there is little dispute about that, the plastics industry, supported by several studies from government agencies in Japan, North America and Europe, contends that polycarbonate bottles contain very little of the chemical and release only insignificant amounts of B.P.A. into the bodies of users. “Rarely has a chemical been the subject of such intense scientific testing and scrutiny, and still, important agencies across the globe agree that there is no danger posed to humans from polycarbonate bottles,” Tom Cummins, the director of Research and Development Department at Nalge Nunc, said in a statement.
Rick Smith, the executive director of Environmental Defence, said that a paper published by 38 scientists after a government-sponsored conference in the United States found that the lack of research on the effects of B.P.A. on humans was a concern that required further investigation. Steven G. Hentges, the executive director of the American Chemistry Council's polycarbonate group, takes issue with that report's worries and points to a separate expert panel report published by the United States Department of Health and Human Services last month. In its 396-page report, which looked only at the impact of B.P.A. on reproduction, the panel said it had “negligible concern” about the chemical's effect on adult reproductive systems but raised some concerns about its impact on children and pregnant women.
1. The word “ubiquitous” (Line 2, Paragraph 3) most probably means _____.
[A] omnipresent
[B] popular
[C] common
[D] usual
2. Which one of the following statements is TRUE of the local law passed by San Francisco's board of governors?
[A] This law forbade the use of B.P.A. in food containers for children.
[B] This law was not enforced because of an industry lawsuit that was against the use of B.P.A.
[C] This law was revised to allow B.P.A. be used in children's products.
[D] This law went into effect before B.P.A. was removed.
3. According to Tom Cummins, which one of the following is NOT true of B.P.A. ?
[A] B.P.A. is rarely tested and scrutinized so intensely.
[B] The testing and scrutiny done to the other chemical are no comparison with that to B.P.A.
[C] That Polycarbonate bottles containing B.P.A. are not dangerous to humans is supported by multiple evidences.
[D] Polycarbonate bottles containing B.P.A. can be used safely by humans.
4. From the separate expert panel report it can be inferred that _____.
[A] B.P.A. has no effect on reproduction
[B] B.P.A. has trifling impact on children and pregnant women
[C] B.P.A. has trifling impact on adult reproductive systems
[D] B.P.A. has great effect on reproduction
5. The author's attitude to the use of Nalgene bottles can be said to be _____.
[A] negative
[B] positive
[C] biased
[D] unclear
1. The word “ubiquitous” (Line 2, Paragraph 3) most probably means _____.
[A] omnipresent
[B] popular
[C] common
[D] usual
1. ubiquitous(第三段第二行)這個(gè)詞最有可能的意思是 _____。
[A] 無所不在的
[B] 普遍的
[C] 普通的
[D] 平常的
答案:A 難度系數(shù):☆☆☆
分析:猜詞題。要根據(jù)上下文來判斷該詞的意思,文章第三段講,當(dāng)時(shí)由于加拿大教會(huì)和環(huán)境組織害怕大量使用塑料制造容器,所以發(fā)動(dòng)了許多運(yùn)動(dòng)。而因?yàn)镹algene牌的瓶子可以重復(fù)使用,具有環(huán)保特征,因此在校園和其他許多地方應(yīng)該是普及了,到處能看得到了。因此,答案為A。
2. Which one of the following statements is TRUE of the local law passed by San Francisco's board of governors?
[A] This law forbade the use of B. P. A. in food containers for children.
[B] This law was not enforced because of an industry lawsuit that was against the use of B. P. A.
[C] This law was revised to allow B. P. A. be used in chil-dren's products.
[D] This law went into effect before B. P. A was removed.
2. 關(guān)于舊金山州長會(huì)議上通過的法律,下列哪個(gè)選項(xiàng)是正確的?
[A] 該法律禁止在兒童的食品容器的制造過程中使用B. P. A.。
[B] 該法律因?yàn)橐粋€(gè)行業(yè)法反對(duì)使用B. P. A.而沒有得以實(shí)施。
[C] 該法律經(jīng)修訂后,允許在兒童產(chǎn)品中使用B. P. A.。
[D] 該法律在移除B. P. A. 之前已經(jīng)生效。
答案:C 難度系數(shù):☆☆☆
分析:細(xì)節(jié)題。文章第四段提到,舊金山州長會(huì)議曾經(jīng)通過了一項(xiàng)法律,該法律禁止在兒童產(chǎn)品中使用B. P. A. , 但是這個(gè)法律還沒有實(shí)施的時(shí)候,就因?yàn)橛幸粋€(gè)行業(yè)訴訟,B. P. A. 就被從這項(xiàng)法律中除去了。由此可以推測(cè),該法律可能同時(shí)規(guī)定了幾種化學(xué)物質(zhì)都不能用于制造兒童產(chǎn)品,后來只是重新修訂了該法律,將B. P. A. 除去了。因此,答案C符合題意。
3. According to Tom Cummins, which one of the following is NOT true of B. P. A.?
[A] B. P. A. is rarely tested and scrutinized so intensely.
[B] The testing and scrutiny done to the other chemical are no comparison with that to B. P. A.
[C] That polycarbonate bottles containing B. P. A. are not dangerous to humans is supported by multiple evidences.
[D] Polycarbonate bottles containing B. P. A. can be used safely by humans.
3. 根據(jù)Tom Cummins所說的,關(guān)于B. P. A.,下列哪個(gè)選項(xiàng)是不正確的?
[A] B. P. A. 很少受到這么嚴(yán)格的審查和檢測(cè)。
[B] 對(duì)其他化學(xué)物質(zhì)所做的審查和檢測(cè)無法與B. P. A. 相比。
[C] 有多種證據(jù)顯示,含有B. P. A. 的聚碳酸酯瓶子對(duì)人類沒有危險(xiǎn)。
[D] 含有B. P. A. 的聚碳酸酯瓶子可以讓人類安全地使用。
答案:A 難度系數(shù):☆☆☆
分析:細(xì)節(jié)題。這個(gè)題目是有關(guān)Tom Cummins的看法的,這在第五段有所提及。選項(xiàng)A和B都針對(duì)他陳述的前半部分內(nèi)容,關(guān)鍵是看這個(gè)句子如何理解:Rarely has a chemical been the subject of such intense scientific testing and scrutiny...,意思是說很少有一種化學(xué)物質(zhì)能受到這么嚴(yán)格的測(cè)驗(yàn),也就是說B. P. A. 受到的測(cè)驗(yàn)很嚴(yán)格,那么選項(xiàng)A是錯(cuò)誤的。選項(xiàng)C和D符合后半句的陳述。因此,答案為A。
4. From the separate expert panel report it can be inferred that _____.
[A] B. P. A. has no effect on reproduction
[B] B. P. A. has trifling impact on children and pregnant women
[C] B. P. A. has trifling impact on adult reproductive systems
[D] B. P. A. has great effect on reproduction
4. 由獨(dú)立專家小組的報(bào)告可以推斷出 _____。
[A] B. P. A. 對(duì)生殖沒有影響
[B] B. P. A. 對(duì)孩子和孕婦有很微弱的影響
[C] B. P. A. 對(duì)成人的生殖系統(tǒng)影響甚微
[D] B. P. A. 對(duì)生殖有很大的影響
答案:C 難度系數(shù):☆☆☆☆
分析:推理題。題干是關(guān)于獨(dú)立專家小組的報(bào)告的,這在文章第六段有所提及。這個(gè)報(bào)告只研究了B. P. A. 對(duì)于生殖的影響,它并不怎么擔(dān)憂該化學(xué)物質(zhì)對(duì)成人生殖系統(tǒng)的影響,但對(duì)該化學(xué)物質(zhì)對(duì)兒童和孕婦的影響卻有一定憂慮。由此可以推斷,該化學(xué)物質(zhì)可能對(duì)兒童和孕婦有一定影響,但對(duì)成人的生殖系統(tǒng)影響不大。選項(xiàng)A說對(duì)生殖沒有影響,過于絕對(duì),因?yàn)槲闹卸啻翁岬接幸欢ㄓ绊懀皇呛艽?。因此,答案為C。
5. The author's attitude to the use of Nalgene bottles can be said to be _____.
[A] negative
[B] positive
[C] biased
[D] unclear
5. 作者對(duì)于使用Nalgene牌瓶子的態(tài)度可以說是 _____。
[A] 否定的
[B] 肯定的
[C] 有偏見的
[D] 不明朗的
答案:B 難度系數(shù):☆
分析:態(tài)度題。這篇文章分析了人們對(duì)于聚碳酸酯瓶子中的化學(xué)物質(zhì)B. P. A. 的看法和爭議,列出了一些科學(xué)研究和判斷的結(jié)果,可以得出結(jié)論,就是該瓶子中的B. P. A. 對(duì)人類的影響有限,因此作者對(duì)使用該瓶子的態(tài)度是肯定的。
由于擔(dān)心在其制造過程中使用了一種化學(xué)物質(zhì),一款本來已經(jīng)成為環(huán)保標(biāo)志的水瓶在加拿大最有名的戶外用品零售柜臺(tái)下架。
周三,位于不列顛哥倫比亞省溫哥華市的高山設(shè)備合作商店將其11個(gè)大型商場(chǎng)中Nalgene牌的瓶子和其他聚碳酸酯容器下架。該零售商稱,不會(huì)再重新進(jìn)這些瓶子,直到加拿大衛(wèi)生署完成了雙酚-a(即B.P.A.)的調(diào)查后再予以考慮是否恢復(fù)進(jìn)貨。這些瓶子由位于羅徹斯特的Nalge Nunc國際公司制造,該公司隸屬Thermo Fisher Scientific。雙酚-a是一種用于制造高硬度透明塑料及食物罐鑲條的化學(xué)物質(zhì)。“高山設(shè)備”的發(fā)言人Tim Southam說:“我們跟蹤B.P.A.事件至少已經(jīng)有三年了,我們這周所做的決定并不說明今后聚碳酸酯制品永遠(yuǎn)都不會(huì)上架了。我們目前試圖得到關(guān)于這種化學(xué)物質(zhì)的確切信息。”
加拿大教會(huì)和環(huán)境組織曾經(jīng)因?yàn)閾?dān)心制造容器需要使用大量的塑料而發(fā)動(dòng)了反對(duì)瓶裝水的運(yùn)動(dòng)。最后,這種可重復(fù)使用的Nalgene牌的瓶子就在大學(xué)校園和其他地方普及開來。
聚碳酸酯塑料只能用B.P.A.制造,用這種塑料制造的瓶子是透明的,硬度幾乎與玻璃一樣,卻非常防摔。但是最近,總部在加拿大多倫多的環(huán)境防衛(wèi)組織對(duì)使用B.P.A.塑料制造的食品容器提出了質(zhì)疑。美國的環(huán)境保護(hù)主義者也日益關(guān)注該化學(xué)物質(zhì)。去年,舊金山的州長會(huì)議通過了一項(xiàng)地方法律,禁止將該化學(xué)物質(zhì)用于兒童用品。但是,在該法令還沒有實(shí)施之前,B.P.A.就在一起行業(yè)訴訟后被從該法律中移除了。批評(píng)者指出,早在1936年就有研究表明,這種化學(xué)物質(zhì)可以破壞荷爾蒙系統(tǒng)。
雖然在這點(diǎn)上沒有爭議,但是塑料行業(yè)引用了日本、北美洲和歐洲政府機(jī)構(gòu)的幾項(xiàng)研究,認(rèn)為聚碳酸酯中該化學(xué)物質(zhì)的含量極少,且只會(huì)將微量的B.P.A.釋放到使用者體內(nèi)。“對(duì)一種化學(xué)物質(zhì)進(jìn)行如此周密的科學(xué)測(cè)驗(yàn)和審查是很罕見的,再說全世界的重要機(jī)構(gòu)都認(rèn)為聚碳酸酯瓶對(duì)人體沒有危害。” Nalge Nunc研發(fā)部主任Tom Cumins在一次聲明中這樣說。
環(huán)境防衛(wèi)組織的執(zhí)行理事Rick Smith稱,38名科學(xué)家在一次政府資助的會(huì)議結(jié)束后在美國發(fā)表了一篇論文,該論文指出,B.P.A.對(duì)人類的影響方面的研究不足,需要進(jìn)行進(jìn)一步的調(diào)查。美國化學(xué)委員會(huì)聚碳酸酯小組執(zhí)行理事Steven G. Hentges反對(duì)該報(bào)告提出的擔(dān)憂,指出上個(gè)月美國健康與人類服務(wù)部發(fā)表了一篇獨(dú)立的專家小組報(bào)告。這個(gè)長達(dá)396頁的報(bào)告中僅僅側(cè)重于B.P.A.對(duì)于生殖的影響,該專家小組在報(bào)告中表示,該化學(xué)物質(zhì)對(duì)成人的生殖系統(tǒng)“影響甚微”,但表示對(duì)孩子和懷孕的婦女有一定影響。